Blog 32 February 17, 2022
Often, it
seems these days, there is public pressure to submit to a pre-ordained
profession of pride, e.g. “America, right or wrong.” Most simply put, it can
attenuate to a required declaration of pride as an American citizen. Do I feel
pride as an American? Sometimes, but not automatically. I do flush with pride
when we, as a nation, do something right, something that tilts us closer to
achieving our stated ideals, something that reflects who we can be to the world.
In my novels, I try to imbue my protagonists with a congruent morality.
I have,
however, also experienced doubt, even shame, not only over what our country has done historically, but
at our current efforts at denial. Same
country, different channels.
Not
infrequently, I hear people speak of pride in being (fill in the blank), citing
a race, a hue, an ethnicity, a religion, a gender. My ethnic heritage is at
least fifty percent Irish. Am I proud
of that? Frankly, pride doesn’t seem to enter into my reaction. But I enjoy the connection. I feel positive about the historical roots
of people who survived attempted genocide by starvation and indifference while
managing to produce a stream of writers and poets who contributed to the
literary canon.
Pride for me personally, relates to accomplishment, not to an accident of
birth. If I strive to do something (writing a novel) and I do it well (to be
determined), I very likely will feel the blush of pride, briefly. Again for me, it’s akin to being an American. My responsibility
is to display good citizenship; in return, my country owes me good governance.
When we behave badly as citizens or as a country, why would I take pride in
that?
I do feel fortunate to be an American, feel positive about doing my share to
help my country be what it could be by striving to be what I can be, to achieve
the standards I try to hold myself to. An example of this effort: a refusal on
my part to allow political mania or expediency carry me off into a
soul-decaying resentment of others or to surrender to the lure of a convenient
explanation to make sense of a dizzying array of complex data.
I am deeply grateful to my country for allowing me
opportunities I might not have in too many other countries, e.g. the freedom to
express myself through the written word. How many Russians or (again, fill in
the blank) would feel at ease expressing these feeling in writing?
Funny I was just thinking about that this morning on my drive in to town! So many people take pride in things their ancestors did, or made or built. At the same time they also do their best to refuse to admit their ancestors did some shameful things as well. They do both these things for the same reason: they feel they automatically share by proxy the pride or shame of those people – people they never even met!
ReplyDeleteBut those people died a long time ago. We can only get so much mileage out of what long-dead ancestors did or didn’t do. At some point we have to do something, ourselves, in which to take pride (or shame, as the case may be.)
I like the way you make the distinction between feeling proud vs feeling fortunate. We’ve been given great blessings, thanks to our ancestors. But a blessing is also a responsibility. If we really want to thank and honor our ancestors, we need to do more than just “be proud.” We need to continue building on the dream they had for their descendants: a better world for all. If we don’t do that, we really have nothing at all to be proud of.